Updated May 7, 2014 - 6:26 pm
Judge refuses to halt order over voter citizenship
WICHITA, Kan. (AP) -- Voters in Kansas and Arizona will have to provide proof of their U.S. citizenship when registering to vote using the federal form even as a U.S. agency appeals a federal judge's order that helps those states enforce their voter registration requirements, the judge ruled Wednesday.
U.S. District Eric Melgren rejected the requests from the U.S. Election Assistance Commission and voting rights groups to put his earlier ruling on hold while the case goes to the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. Melgren ruled on March 19 that the commission must immediately modify a national voter registration form to add special instructions for Arizona and Kansas residents about those states' proof-of-citizenship requirements.
The commission contends that the added documentation burdens result in an overall decrease in registration of eligible citizens, undermining the purpose of the National Voter Registration Act. The states argue the requirement protects the integrity of their elections by ensuring noncitizens aren't voting.
Melgren ordered the commission to carry out "forthwith without further delay" his March 19 directive. The judge wrote that the commission and its supporters had not shown that the public interest is best served by suspending his ruling.
"Public interest is best expressed through laws enacted by the public's elected representatives," Melgren wrote in a nine-page ruling. "The people of Arizona and the representatives of Kansas have decided that the public interest of their residents is in preventing voter fraud and protecting public confidence in the integrity of their elections."
Melgren also said that the voting rights groups have not proven anyone will be denied the right to vote as a result of the state laws. Thus the inability to register voters is "only theoretical," the judge said.
Bryan Whitener, a spokesman for the commission, said in an email that the agency was reviewing the ruling and exploring its options.
Kansas Secretary of State Kris Kobach told The Associated Press said it's significant that the judge found that the harm to Kansas and Arizona outweigh the alleged harm to the federal agency.
"It is shocking that the federal government waited 49 days and refused to comply with a federal court order," Kobach said. "The rule of law requires parties to comply with a federal order. Here we have the federal government thinking it can defy a federal court order."
The election commission had argued that it is likely to succeed on appeal because Melgren's order conflicts with a U.S. Supreme Court decision last year, among other things.
Arizona enacted its proof-of-citizenship requirement by voter initiative in 2004, and Alabama, Georgia and Kansas followed with similar laws. Most voters in Arizona and Kansas register with state forms, but their officials said the availability of the federal form created a loophole in enforcement of proof-of-citizenship requirements.
Some 17,604 Kansans now have their voter registrations on hold as a result of the requirement.
Associated Press writer John Hanna contributed to this report from Overland Park, Kan.
Copyright © The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.