It's being called the Right to Refuse Service bill.
The law is meant to protect business owners from lawsuits if they refuse service to people based on their "sincerely held religious beliefs," but it's so much more than just that.
The headline CNN ran on Friday afternoon said "Arizona may let businesses ban gays." So the impression Arizona lawmakers create is of a state that doesn't tolerate gays, when just a couple of years ago Arizona was labeled the anti-Hispanic state (see SB 1070 and Sheriff Joe Arpaio's racial profiling lawsuit). That's the bigger problem with SB 1062 and that's why Gov. Jan Brewer should veto it.
Friday on the Rob and Karie Show, Kristen Jarnagin, senior vice president of the Arizona Lodging and Tourism Association, said her office has already received calls from people canceling their spring training trips here because of this bill, which is still one step away from becoming law. Brewer has until Friday to either sign it or veto it.
Jarnagin added Arizona's economy is reliant on tourism. It is a $19.3 billion industry that accounts for 200,000 jobs. Giving people a reason not to come here isn't in Arizona's best interests. Lawmakers are supposed to protect those interests.
Sure, business owners deserve rights and protections. This is the wrong way to go about it.
First, because the bill only protects business owners rights if they hold "sincerely held religious beliefs." That is about as subjective as it gets because beliefs and where they come from are nearly impossible to disprove. This could turn Arizona's courts into religious testing grounds where a business owner might have to take a religion test, submit their Church attendance history or Bible readings in order to prove whether or not the beliefs are "sincere."
Secondly, why are "religious" beliefs given extra protection over non-religious beliefs? The way SB 1062 reads allows only religious business owners to refuse service to anyone. That, in and of itself, is discrimination.
Thirdly, there is no great need for this bill. There are no pending lawsuits arguing business discrimination in Arizona. The New Mexico lawsuit that spurred this law was first filed back in 2006. Last year, after seven years bouncing around courts, the New Mexico Supreme Court ruled in favor of a gay couple who sued a wedding photographer saying refusing service to them based on their sexuality "is no different than refusing to photograph a wedding between people of different races."
So this bill, SB1062, may not be Constitutional even if it becomes law in Arizona. Just because the legislature passed it and Brewer may sign does not mean it won't stand up to Constitutional muster. The fight over this bill could potentially cost the state millions of dollars.
The final reason Brewer should veto this bill is because the architects of it are trying to score political points with their constituency. That's the motivation behind SB 1062. Arizona Republicans are simply sending the message that they are fighting for the rights of the religious.
No, they are actually just pandering to get their votes. And they're doing it again at the expense of Arizona's reputation.
- SB 1062 opposition begins pushing back
- Lawyer says SB 1062 fight is just beginning
- Gov. Jan Brewer vetoes SB 1062
- CAP President: Veto marks 'tragic day'
- Arizona politicians react to SB 1062 veto
- Council thanks Brewer for SB 1062 veto
- Rob's 5: Big black eyes in Arizona history
- Brewer holds meetings on SB 1062
- Report: NFL may move Super Bowl from AZ
- The basics of SB 1062
- Final Word: AZ out to make a fool of itself?
- AZ senator defends SB 1062 on 'AC360'
- Meghan McCain 'horrified' at SB 1062
- Farmer throws support behind SB 1062
- SB 1062 could affect 2015 Super Bowl
- Group addresses 'misinformation' about bill
- St. James: Should AZ care what others think?
- Karie: SB 1062 Stand Your Ground for bigots
- McMahon: Bon appetit, Arizona
- Foster: 'We reserve the right'
- Senator: 'Lapse' when voting for SB 1062
- Hispanic lawyers pull AZ conference
- Official: Arizona tourism loses with SB 1062
- Expert: Bill won't derail economic recovery
- Valley restaurant takes stand against bill
- Phx business showing SB 1062 disgust
- Go Daddy releases anti-SB 1062 statement
- George Takei rips Arizona over SB 1062
- Apple adds to anti-SB 1062 sentiments
- State treasurer says veto Arizona bill
- Three senators urge veto of SB 1062
- Service refusal bill bad for Ariz. taxpayers
- SB 1062 opponents protest at capitol
- Council urges Brewer to veto SB 1062
- AZ governor hopefuls weigh in on SB 1062
- Religious service bill riles gay supporters
- Eyes on Education A view of Arizona's education system from all angles.