ARIZONA NEWS

Arizona inmates can sue state for failure to accomodate disability on job

Sep 25, 2013, 6:51 AM | Updated: 6:51 am

WASHINGTON — A federal appeals court said the state can be sued by an Arizona inmate contracted out to a private company that he said violated his rights by failing to accommodate his disability on the job.

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said Tuesday that William Castle could not sue Eurofresh for violating the Americans with Disabilities Act because Castle, a contract inmate laborer, was not an “employee” of the produce company.

But a three-judge panel of the court also said state officials could not “contract away their obligation to comply with federal discrimination laws,” and it ordered a lower court to reconsider whether workplace discrimination had occurred.

An attorney for Castle declined in an email to comment and a spokeswoman for the Arizona Attorney General’s office said Tuesday that the office was “still reviewing the case” and would not comment at this time.

Castle, 48, was in prison on a Maricopa County theft conviction in July 2008 when he was contracted through Arizona Correctional Industries to work for Eurofresh, which describes itself as “America’s largest greenhouse operation,” according to the court ruling.

Under state law, all able-bodied inmates are required to “engage in hard labor for not less than 40 hours per week.” That is typically done through the Department of Corrections’ Work Incentive Pay Program, which pays inmates 10 to 50 cents per hour.

But contract work through ACI is more lucrative – Castle was earning more than $2.25 an hour picking tomatoes at Eurofresh, the court said. It said he was on his feet for his entire seven-hour shift and had to push a 600-pound cart for the “strenuous” job.

By late August, Castle began experiencing “intolerable pain and swelling” in his left ankle, which had been injured decades earlier while he was in the Army Airborne School. But a supervisor told him he would be fired if he took breaks to rest his ankle.

Castle’s medical provider suggested that he ask for a job change or accommodation. But after meetings with Eurofresh and ACI officials, he said he was told there were no other positions for him and there would be no accommodations. The state and Eurofresh claim he was offered another job that he turned down.

Eventually, Castle was transferred out of the ACI contract program and back to a WIPP job in the prison motor pool, where his pay dropped to 50 cents an hour.

Castle filed a discrimination claim charging that Eurofresh and the state violated his rights under the Americans with Disabilities Act and the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 by “failing to accommodate his disability.”

A federal district court dismissed Castle’s ADA claim against the company, as he “did not have an employment relationship with Eurofresh.” And it said that the Rehabilitation Act did not apply because Eurofresh did not receive federal financial assistance.

The district court later held that Castle could not sue the state, since he was ultimately given another job, even if it was at a lower salary.

Castle, who was released from prison in April, appealed.

While the appeals court agreed that Eurofresh could not be sued, it overturned the lower court on the state’s liability. The panel said that the state is obliged to ensure that Eurofresh, the contractor, complies with federal laws prohibiting discrimination on the basis of disability.

The question of whether discrimination actually occurred, however, was a question that needed to be determined by the district court, said the appeals panel, which remanded the case with instructions to answer that question.

Jeffrey Willis, an attorney for Eurofresh, said the company was “pleased” that the court agreed that inmates contracted for work through the Department of Corrections “are not considered employees or members of the industry.”

We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Pass it along to the KTAR News team here.

Arizona News

indicted in fake elector scheme Arizona Republicans...

KTAR.com

State grand jury indicts 11 Arizona Republicans in fake elector investigation

Eleven defendants were indicted in a fake elector scheme on Wednesday, according to Arizona Attorney General Kris Mayes.

2 hours ago

Boy injured after hit-and-run died, Glendale police say...

KTAR.com

13-year-old boy hit by truck in Glendale 2 weeks ago dies

The Glendale Police Department announced that a 13-year-old boy injured by a hit-and-run died on Tuesday after two weeks in the hospital.

4 hours ago

Image shows Chucho Produce facility in Nogales. (Chucho Produce)...

SuElen Rivera

4 Arizona businesses get nearly $1M from USDA for clean energy projects

The funding totaling $975,000 was provided by the Inflation Reduction Act, according to the Department of Agriculture.

5 hours ago

A collage of photos showing a wooden raft, a headshot of Thomas L. Robison, and a photo of the miss...

KTAR.com

Man who may have taken homemade raft onto Colorado River in Arizona goes missing

A man who may have been trying to float down the Colorado River with his dog on a homemade raft is missing.

6 hours ago

Split image of the Arizona flag on the left and state Rep. Matt Gress on the House floor April 24, ...

KTAR.com

Democrats in Arizona House get enough GOP help to pass bill to repeal near-total abortion ban

Arizona House Democrats, with help from a few Republicans, passed a bill Wednesday to repeal the state’s near-total abortion ban.

7 hours ago

Follow @suelenrivera...

SuElen Rivera

Arizona’s oldest predominantly Black community listed on National Register of Historic Places

The Randolph Townsite Historic District located 50 miles southeast of Phoenix was listed as a traditional cultural place.

8 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

...

Day & Night Air Conditioning, Heating and Plumbing

Day & Night is looking for the oldest AC in the Valley

Does your air conditioner make weird noises or a burning smell when it starts? If so, you may be due for an AC unit replacement.

...

Collins Comfort Masters

Avoid a potential emergency and get your home’s heating and furnace safety checked

With the weather getting colder throughout the Valley, the best time to make sure your heating is all up to date is now. 

(KTAR News Graphic)...

Boys & Girls Clubs

KTAR launches online holiday auction benefitting Boys & Girls Clubs of the Valley

KTAR is teaming up with The Boys & Girls Clubs of the Valley for a holiday auction benefitting thousands of Valley kids.

Arizona inmates can sue state for failure to accomodate disability on job